{ "status": "completed", "applicable_count": 1, "completed_count": 1, "failed_count": 0, "generative_count": 0, "reused_count": 0, "round_replayed_count": 0, "schema_version": 5, "config_hash": "0c0ba98fee2bc515077e65dc76b25a140f4da294a90380de034d4d51a737da28", "data": { "groups": { "bg_mine_complex": { "status": "ok", "group_id": "bg_mine_complex", "form_ref_path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_05.png", "form_ref_sha256": "16b856258ab05330655f97de7e4bb8f3eddf0c0f64948faa7937927c61728fe3", "chosen_prompt_used": "Find real photographs only of ordinary, extensive Pennsylvania forest and woodland. Use present-day photographs as references for this ordinary natural subject; do not add the unphotographable future year to the queries. Prioritize everyday forest interiors and broad valley forest cover rather than tourist attractions, landmarks, famous overlooks, travel guides, booking pages, decorative landscapes, concept art, illustrations, maps, or generated images. Read the forest’s physical structure, tree proportions, density, natural materials, bark and foliage textures, colours, and continuity of cover from the photographs. Take form only: never copy a photograph’s layout, camera angle, framing, weather, time of day, or surroundings. Write every query only in English and never generate an image.", "candidate_count": 6, "source_website_url": "https://www.wayfair.co.uk/home-decor/pdp/alpen-home-pennsylvania-wilds-u110347831.html", "fitting_refs": [], "typology": { "block": "RESEARCHED FACTS — what a place of this KIND actually looks like, looked up from real examples (photographs included) because neither the screenplay nor the STRUCTURE SPEC says anything about it:\nWhere the screenplay or the STRUCTURE SPEC settles a matter, that wins and you ignore the line below. EVERYWHERE ELSE THESE FACTS SETTLE IT — they are here to replace your own impression of the type, which is what would otherwise fill the gap. Write what they describe into the picture as concrete visual fact, in the same plain physical sentences as everything else. They are about the type and not about this particular place, so never present them as something the screenplay stated. Never state the absence of something merely because it is not listed here.\nEach line is marked [corroborated] when both researchers reported the same thing, or [single source] when only one found a basis. Treat a [single source] line as a tendency worth following, not as a fact to assert — never write it into the brief as something the place certainly has, and never let it force a count or a negation.\nIf a line mentions a real name it saw on an example, that is an observation about how such places are named, never a name to reuse. This place's own name comes from what the screenplay supplies.\n- (원통형으로 도려내진 건물 잔해) [corroborated] When a giant cylindrical structure like a concrete silo is missing from a complex, the exposed ruin typically features tall, vertically continuous concave bays separated by narrow triangular or star-shaped junction ribs, with irregular broken rims exposing reinforcement at the top and fragments of inward-sloping conical hoppers at the bottom.\n- (비스듬히 기운 콘크리트 고층건물 골조) [single source] No Korean-language source can document a Pennsylvania or North American ruin in the year 2419, so there is no evidence for a setting-specific norm. In comparable photographs and Korean structural-damage records, the recurring form is not a tower smoothly bent like a reed. The surviving upper frame usually remains a fairly rigid rectangular block, while a weakened lower or middle story crushes more on one side, creating a wedge-shaped void and rotating the block diagonally. Draw the ruin in three zones: an upper grid of exposed floor plates and upright columns; a transition zone where slabs are broken into descending steps, corners are missing, and reinforcing bars hang from jagged edges; and a broad base mound containing collapsed slabs, column fragments, and soil. Some floor plates remain stacked close together locally, while other bays are completely open. The downhill face commonly has the largest missing corner and rubble accumulation. Openings form a repetitive dark rectangular grid, comparable to rows of rooms, but vegetation interrupts it irregularly: trees rise through missing floors, vines descend from roof and slab edges, and dense growth conceals the ground story. The main color divisions are pale or brownish gray concrete, near-black interiors and damp streaks, orange-brown rust around exposed reinforcement, and concentrated green vegetation at the roof, cracks, open bays, and buried base. This is an evidence-based analogue, not a verified description of Pennsylvania after centuries of abandonment or of 2419.", "items": [ { "target_native": "비스듬히 기운 콘크리트 고층건물 골조", "question_native": "미국 펜실베이니아 일대 및 2419년 원미래 북아메리카권에서 수백 년간 자연에 재점유되어 비스듬히 기운 콘크리트 고층건물 골조는 보통 어떤 붕괴 형태로 보이는가?", "answer_a": "No Korean-language source can document a Pennsylvania or North American ruin in the year 2419, so there is no evidence for a setting-specific norm. In comparable photographs and Korean structural-damage records, the recurring form is not a tower smoothly bent like a reed. The surviving upper frame usually remains a fairly rigid rectangular block, while a weakened lower or middle story crushes more on one side, creating a wedge-shaped void and rotating the block diagonally. Draw the ruin in three zones: an upper grid of exposed floor plates and upright columns; a transition zone where slabs are broken into descending steps, corners are missing, and reinforcing bars hang from jagged edges; and a broad base mound containing collapsed slabs, column fragments, and soil. Some floor plates remain stacked close together locally, while other bays are completely open. The downhill face commonly has the largest missing corner and rubble accumulation. Openings form a repetitive dark rectangular grid, comparable to rows of rooms, but vegetation interrupts it irregularly: trees rise through missing floors, vines descend from roof and slab edges, and dense growth conceals the ground story. The main color divisions are pale or brownish gray concrete, near-black interiors and damp streaks, orange-brown rust around exposed reinforcement, and concentrated green vegetation at the roof, cracks, open bays, and buried base. This is an evidence-based analogue, not a verified description of Pennsylvania after centuries of abandonment or of 2419.", "answer_b": "I did not find a Korean-language canonical description or a repeated photographic pattern establishing a “usual” collapse form for a centuries-old, nature-reclaimed, leaning concrete high-rise frame in Pennsylvania or in the original 2419 North American setting. Korean materials identify Armageddon 2419 A.D. as the original Buck Rogers story, while Pennsylvania photographs mainly show surviving industrial shells, furnaces, masonry walls, and steelwork rather than tilted concrete skyscraper skeletons. Modern reinforced-concrete collapse photographs repeatedly show progressive local floor loss—broken slabs descending around surviving columns, diagonal slab fragments, ragged concrete edges, and curtain-like exposed reinforcement—but these are recent accidents or demolition scenes. Applying that appearance to several centuries of decay would be unsupported extrapolation, so no defensible standard visual form was found.", "sources": [ "https://2ravelaroundtheworld.tistory.com/entry/%EB%AF%B8%EA%B5%AD-%EC%B5%9C%EB%8C%80-%EC%B2%A0%EA%B0%95-%EA%B3%B5%EC%9E%A5%EC%9D%98-%EB%B3%80%EC%8B%A0-Steel-Stacks-%ED%8E%9C%EC%8B%A4%EB%B2%A0%EC%9D%B4%EB%8B%88%EC%95%84-%EC%A3%BC-%EB%B2%A0%EB%93%A4%EB%A0%88%ED%97%B4-%EC%97%AC%ED%96%89-%EB%AF%B8%EA%B5%AD-%EB%89%B4%EC%9A%95-%EA%B7%BC%EA%B5%90-%EC%97%AC%ED%96%89-%EC%B6%94%EC%B2%9C", "https://unsplash.com/ko/%EC%82%AC%EC%A7%84/%EC%8B%9D%EB%AC%BC%EC%9D%B4-%EC%9E%90%EB%9D%BC%EB%8A%94-%EC%BD%98%ED%81%AC%EB%A6%AC%ED%8A%B8-%EB%B2%BD%EC%9D%98-%EA%B7%A0%EC%97%B4-ECAkOozVuhg", "https://v.daum.net/v/cAKux6R6mo?f=p", "https://v.daum.net/v/unf0ekaVpB?f=p", "https://www.codil.or.kr/filebank/original/TR/OTKNTR000169//OTKNTR000169.pdf", "https://www.jungdoilbo.com/news/article.html?no=117756", "https://www.kalis.or.kr/wpge/m_201/info/info070201.do", "https://www.korea.kr/news/policyNewsView.do?newsId=156499293", "https://www.reddit.com/r/urbanexploration/comments/6ckimk/abandoned_factory_pa_usa/?tl=ko" ], "adopted": true, "agree": false, "strength": "weak", "reason_ko": "한쪽(A)만 근거 확보 — 단독 근거로 약하게 채택(단정 아님)", "agreed_fact_en": "No Korean-language source can document a Pennsylvania or North American ruin in the year 2419, so there is no evidence for a setting-specific norm. In comparable photographs and Korean structural-damage records, the recurring form is not a tower smoothly bent like a reed. The surviving upper frame usually remains a fairly rigid rectangular block, while a weakened lower or middle story crushes more on one side, creating a wedge-shaped void and rotating the block diagonally. Draw the ruin in three zones: an upper grid of exposed floor plates and upright columns; a transition zone where slabs are broken into descending steps, corners are missing, and reinforcing bars hang from jagged edges; and a broad base mound containing collapsed slabs, column fragments, and soil. Some floor plates remain stacked close together locally, while other bays are completely open. The downhill face commonly has the largest missing corner and rubble accumulation. Openings form a repetitive dark rectangular grid, comparable to rows of rooms, but vegetation interrupts it irregularly: trees rise through missing floors, vines descend from roof and slab edges, and dense growth conceals the ground story. The main color divisions are pale or brownish gray concrete, near-black interiors and damp streaks, orange-brown rust around exposed reinforcement, and concentrated green vegetation at the roof, cracks, open bays, and buried base. This is an evidence-based analogue, not a verified description of Pennsylvania after centuries of abandonment or of 2419." }, { "target_native": "원통형으로 도려내진 건물 잔해", "question_native": "미국 펜실베이니아 일대 및 2419년 원미래 북아메리카권에서 거대한 원통형 부분이 사라진 오래된 건물 잔해의 노출 단면은 보통 어떤 모습인가?", "answer_a": "No Korean-language material establishes a usual exposed section specifically for Pennsylvania or the year 2419. For comparable concrete silo and grain-elevator structures, however, plans, cutaway drawings, demolition studies, and photographs repeatedly show the following drawable anatomy. The missing cylinder leaves a tall concave bay bounded by two curved vertical wall remnants rather than an ordinary flat room section. At each broken side, show an outer weathered surface, a thick speckled concrete core, and an inner curved surface; the fracture line is irregular and fringed with projecting or drooping reinforcement. Near the bottom, the characteristic surviving element is a funnel-like internal cone: two diagonal concrete faces descend toward a small central discharge passage, often with short supporting walls or columns beneath. If that cone has also failed, its former position remains readable as two diagonal scars converging toward the center. At the top, fragments of a ring-shaped rim or shallow conical roof may remain. In a group of joined silos, removal of one cylinder exposes repeated scalloped arcs; between neighboring arcs are narrow pointed webs that appear triangular at an outside edge and star-like where several cylinders originally met. The cavity is comparable in width to a cluster of rooms and extends through many ordinary floor levels, while attached service buildings retain much smaller rectangular doors, windows, stairs, and platforms, making the circular absence visually dominant. Use pale gray or faded painted outer faces, darker gray-brown interior curves, rusty orange reinforcement and runoff streaks, almost black recesses around the outlet, and green growth concentrated along the bottom funnel, broken rim, and wall junctions. This description applies to reinforced-concrete silo complexes; I did not find adequate Korean photographic evidence for treating every unidentified missing cylindrical building component this way.", "answer_b": "A supported answer is possible only if the missing giant cylindrical part is interpreted as one cell of a clustered concrete grain or cement silo; I found no 2419-specific depiction. Such complexes consist of repeated circular cells joined in rows. Removing one cell exposes a broad, vertically continuous concave wall face rather than a flat room-by-room section. For drawing, divide the ruin into three zones: at the top, an uneven crescent-shaped broken rim with pale fresh concrete and rust-dark reinforcement projecting from it; through the middle, one or more tall half-round gray recesses, each bordered on both sides by narrow, heavier vertical ribs where neighboring cylinders met; at junctions between several cells, dark diamond- or star-like vertical pockets, while the outer edge produces triangular wedge-shaped pockets; near the bottom, either a flat broken base or inward-sloping cone or pyramid fragments belonging to the discharge hopper. Adjacent surviving cells make the exposed face repeat as alternating concave bays and narrow ribs. Each concave bay is broader than several ordinary rooms placed together and continues past many floor levels; the separating ribs are much narrower, closer to a bank of doors. Weathered surfaces tend to separate visually into light or medium gray concrete, black interior cavities, green growth on ledges and cracks, and reddish-brown reinforcement at broken edges.", "sources": [ "https://kbsilo.com/ko/hopper-bottom-grain-silo-applications-and-discharge-efficiency/", "https://koreascience.kr/article/JAKO201218450946372.pdf", "https://koreascience.or.kr/article/CFKO200908856869643.pdf", "https://patents.google.com/patent/KR101054906B1/ko", "https://patents.google.com/patent/KR20090051293A/ko", "https://unsplash.com/ko/%EC%82%AC%EC%A7%84/%EA%B5%B4%EC%B0%A9%EA%B8%B0%EA%B0%80-%EC%BD%98%ED%81%AC%EB%A6%AC%ED%8A%B8-%EC%82%AC%EC%9D%BC%EB%A1%9C-%EA%B5%AC%EC%A1%B0%EB%AC%BC%EC%9D%84-%EC%B2%A0%EA%B1%B0%ED%95%98%EB%8A%94-%EB%AA%A8%EC%8A%B5%EC%9E%85%EB%8B%88%EB%8B%A4-buvOipu4pLI", "https://www.chosun.com/special/special_section/2022/12/26/LCYVPKS6LNF4LCKSXWVOGUJUVI/", "https://www.getyourguide.com/ko-kr/zeitz-mocaa-l88832/", "https://www.kci.go.kr/kciportal/ci/sereArticleSearch/ciSereArtiView.kci?sereArticleSearchBean.artiId=ART001576086", "https://www.newstomato.com/ReadNews.aspx?no=1168050" ], "adopted": true, "agree": true, "strength": "strong", "agreed_fact_en": "When a giant cylindrical structure like a concrete silo is missing from a complex, the exposed ruin typically features tall, vertically continuous concave bays separated by narrow triangular or star-shaped junction ribs, with irregular broken rims exposing reinforcement at the top and fragments of inward-sloping conical hoppers at the bottom.", "reason_ko": "두 조사자 모두 거대한 원통형 구조물(사일로 등)이 떨어져 나간 단면은 수직으로 길게 이어지는 오목한 벽면과 그 사이의 삼각형 또는 별 모양 이음새, 상단의 철근이 노출된 파손된 테두리, 하단의 원뿔형 깔때기 잔해로 구성된다는 점에 동의하고 있습니다." } ], "questions": [ { "target_native": "비스듬히 기운 콘크리트 고층건물 골조", "question_native": "미국 펜실베이니아 일대 및 2419년 원미래 북아메리카권에서 수백 년간 자연에 재점유되어 비스듬히 기운 콘크리트 고층건물 골조는 보통 어떤 붕괴 형태로 보이는가?", "why_ko": "수목 위로 기울어진 채 남은 고층 골조는 장면의 핵심 표지물이어서 구조적으로 그럴듯한 붕괴 형태를 확인할 필요가 있다." }, { "target_native": "원통형으로 도려내진 건물 잔해", "question_native": "미국 펜실베이니아 일대 및 2419년 원미래 북아메리카권에서 거대한 원통형 부분이 사라진 오래된 건물 잔해의 노출 단면은 보통 어떤 모습인가?", "why_ko": "거대한 원통형 결손은 일반적인 폐허에서 형태를 추정하기 어려운 특이한 시각 정보이므로 단면의 실제적인 표현이 필요하다." } ], "dropped_reason_ko": "숲과 강은 통상적인 자연 지형이고, 뿌리 사이의 갱도 출구는 원문이 필요한 외형을 이미 직접 제시해 별도 조사가 필요하지 않다." }, "audit": { "target_key": "bg_mine_complex", "source_language": "한국어", "search_directive_native": "Find real photographs only of ordinary, extensive Pennsylvania forest and woodland. Use present-day photographs as references for this ordinary natural subject; do not add the unphotographable future year to the queries. Prioritize everyday forest interiors and broad valley forest cover rather than tourist attractions, landmarks, famous overlooks, travel guides, booking pages, decorative landscapes, concept art, illustrations, maps, or generated images. Read the forest’s physical structure, tree proportions, density, natural materials, bark and foliage textures, colours, and continuity of cover from the photographs. Take form only: never copy a photograph’s layout, camera angle, framing, weather, time of day, or surroundings. Write every query only in English and never generate an image.", "search_terms_native": [ "Pennsylvania forest", "Pennsylvania woods", "Pennsylvania woodland" ], "queries": [ [ "real photograph ordinary Pennsylvania forest interior deciduous woodland extensive natural woods", "real photograph broad Pennsylvania valley continuous forest cover ordinary woodland" ] ], "found": 6, "candidates": [ { "index": 1, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_01.png", "sha256": "43eb0feb4480059e36a9a89e17188153db5239da6aa5fd06be76c5e0086b9c4f", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://hipcamp-res.cloudinary.com/images/f_auto%2Cc_limit%2Cw_3840%2Cq_auto%3Abest%3Asensitive/v1622727840/campground-photos/wvlvmh3bmhxtmfof1vmy/forest-house-at-warren-estates-forest-house-at-lake-warren-estates-amish-country.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://www.hipcamp.com/en-US/d/united-states/pennsylvania/gettysburg/camping/cabins", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 55.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 27.5, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 광활한 숲의 모습은 있으나 강이 보이지 않고 계곡 지형의 깊이감이 부족합니다. / gpt: 산림 계곡 전경만 보이며 뿌리에 좁아진 광산 출구 구조는 전혀 확인되지 않는다." }, { "index": 2, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_02.png", "sha256": "491a256c983cd62c36e51e114eb597993792cac85fb29bd38ea842623b122dc4", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://cdn.agentimagehosting.com/fgVRlcmqWdUnxUrrxj6Gp/2026/02/08025621/Graystones-Jeras-Rd-Kidder-Township-PA-003.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://thegambinogroup.com/properties/graystones-preserve/", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 65.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 32.5, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 계곡 숲의 형태는 확인되지만 강이 뚜렷하게 나타나지 않아 다소 아쉽습니다. / gpt: 넓은 산림 계곡을 보여 주지만 광산 출구나 그 구조적 형태가 없다." }, { "index": 3, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_03.png", "sha256": "0a217ad179e26fdf1d34665a20ab2d938f55baa4d3b00eedbfa128e37d1bbbd2", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://www.landbrokermls.com/_next/image?q=75&url=https%3A%2F%2Fimgs.landbrokermls.com%2Fpublic%2Fproperty%2F1269563%2FKqDfNceU1zTfrixcn7dEtcdsmL4KPN1RcsO6I1yD.webp&w=3840", "source_website_url": "https://www.landbrokermls.com/property/1269563/north-fork-forest", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 0.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 숲 내부의 나무를 찍은 근경으로 광대한 계곡 지형을 전혀 보여주지 않습니다. / gpt: 숲 내부 사진일 뿐 뿌리로 협착된 광산 출구는 나타나지 않는다." }, { "index": 4, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_04.png", "sha256": "e491c94d761e5aabe755c9ab99ea31d0c094992a909d7842cc3d3c9379a97591", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://ap.rdcpix.com/a6cac674ceef116c8b459e383e14439bl-m2946915521od-w640_h480.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://www.realtor.com/realestateandhomes-detail/Turkey-Hollow-Rd_Sigel_PA_15860_M93983-58202", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 0.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 평탄한 숲 안쪽을 비추고 있어 넓은 계곡과 강의 구조를 파악할 수 없습니다. / gpt: 일반적인 숲 바닥과 나무만 보이고 광산 출구 구조는 없다." }, { "index": 5, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_05.png", "sha256": "16b856258ab05330655f97de7e4bb8f3eddf0c0f64948faa7937927c61728fe3", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://assets.wfcdn.com/im/22045204/compr-r85/2822/282278993/Pennsylvania%2Bwilds.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://www.wayfair.co.uk/home-decor/pdp/alpen-home-pennsylvania-wilds-u110347831.html", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 90.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 45.0, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 강이 굽이쳐 흐르는 광대한 계곡 숲의 지형과 식생이 매우 명확하게 나타납니다. / gpt: 펜실베이니아풍 산림 계곡과 강은 잘 보이지만 핵심 구조인 광산 출구가 전혀 없다." }, { "index": 6, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_06.png", "sha256": "6eb3197fc8f148d08700493bb3e42cb5ec22f37724cde978ba1ef0747b9b9031", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://hipcamp-res.cloudinary.com/images/f_auto%2Cc_limit%2Cw_3840%2Cq_auto%3Abest%3Asensitive/v1433544206/dmufigzgsg1xvwgfi1e3/cook-forest-park-cook-forest-park-campground.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://www.hipcamp.com/en-US/state-park/united-states/pennsylvania/cook-forest-park/all", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 0.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 쓰러진 나무 중심의 숲 내부 모습으로 전체적인 계곡 지형과는 무관합니다. / gpt: 쓰러진 나무가 있는 숲 내부로, 광산 출구나 뿌리에 의한 협착 형태를 읽을 수 없다." } ], "verdict": { "chosen_index": 5, "judges_used": [ "gemini-pro", "gpt" ], "rejected_judges": {}, "judge_count_per_candidate": 2, "single_judge": false, "averages": { "1": 27.5, "2": 32.5, "3": 0.0, "4": 0.0, "5": 45.0, "6": 0.0 }, "per_candidate": { "1": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 55.0, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "광활한 숲의 모습은 있으나 강이 보이지 않고 계곡 지형의 깊이감이 부족합니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "산림 계곡 전경만 보이며 뿌리에 좁아진 광산 출구 구조는 전혀 확인되지 않는다." } }, "2": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 65.0, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "계곡 숲의 형태는 확인되지만 강이 뚜렷하게 나타나지 않아 다소 아쉽습니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "넓은 산림 계곡을 보여 주지만 광산 출구나 그 구조적 형태가 없다." } }, "3": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "숲 내부의 나무를 찍은 근경으로 광대한 계곡 지형을 전혀 보여주지 않습니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "숲 내부 사진일 뿐 뿌리로 협착된 광산 출구는 나타나지 않는다." } }, "4": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "평탄한 숲 안쪽을 비추고 있어 넓은 계곡과 강의 구조를 파악할 수 없습니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "일반적인 숲 바닥과 나무만 보이고 광산 출구 구조는 없다." } }, "5": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 90.0, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "강이 굽이쳐 흐르는 광대한 계곡 숲의 지형과 식생이 매우 명확하게 나타납니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "펜실베이니아풍 산림 계곡과 강은 잘 보이지만 핵심 구조인 광산 출구가 전혀 없다." } }, "6": { "gemini-pro": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "쓰러진 나무 중심의 숲 내부 모습으로 전체적인 계곡 지형과는 무관합니다." }, "gpt": { "score": 0.0, "usable": false, "reason_ko": "쓰러진 나무가 있는 숲 내부로, 광산 출구나 뿌리에 의한 협착 형태를 읽을 수 없다." } } }, "judge_usage": { "gemini-pro": { "alias": "gemini-pro", "max_tokens_sent": 65536, "physical_model": "gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "prompt_tokens": 8059, "completion_tokens": 2326, "total_tokens": 10385, "estimated_cost_usd": 0.030994 }, "gpt": { "alias": "gpt", "max_tokens_sent": 65536, "physical_model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "prompt_tokens": 6329, "completion_tokens": 474, "total_tokens": 6803, "estimated_cost_usd": 0.034796 } }, "verdicts": [ { "index": 1, "usable": true, "score": 27.5, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 광활한 숲의 모습은 있으나 강이 보이지 않고 계곡 지형의 깊이감이 부족합니다. / gpt: 산림 계곡 전경만 보이며 뿌리에 좁아진 광산 출구 구조는 전혀 확인되지 않는다." }, { "index": 2, "usable": true, "score": 32.5, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 계곡 숲의 형태는 확인되지만 강이 뚜렷하게 나타나지 않아 다소 아쉽습니다. / gpt: 넓은 산림 계곡을 보여 주지만 광산 출구나 그 구조적 형태가 없다." }, { "index": 3, "usable": false, "score": 0.0, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 숲 내부의 나무를 찍은 근경으로 광대한 계곡 지형을 전혀 보여주지 않습니다. / gpt: 숲 내부 사진일 뿐 뿌리로 협착된 광산 출구는 나타나지 않는다." }, { "index": 4, "usable": false, "score": 0.0, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 평탄한 숲 안쪽을 비추고 있어 넓은 계곡과 강의 구조를 파악할 수 없습니다. / gpt: 일반적인 숲 바닥과 나무만 보이고 광산 출구 구조는 없다." }, { "index": 5, "usable": true, "score": 45.0, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 강이 굽이쳐 흐르는 광대한 계곡 숲의 지형과 식생이 매우 명확하게 나타납니다. / gpt: 펜실베이니아풍 산림 계곡과 강은 잘 보이지만 핵심 구조인 광산 출구가 전혀 없다." }, { "index": 6, "usable": false, "score": 0.0, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 쓰러진 나무 중심의 숲 내부 모습으로 전체적인 계곡 지형과는 무관합니다. / gpt: 쓰러진 나무가 있는 숲 내부로, 광산 출구나 뿌리에 의한 협착 형태를 읽을 수 없다." } ], "chosen_reason_ko": "이중 판정 평균 최고 (심판 gemini-pro, gpt)", "per_judge_raw": { "gemini-pro": { "verdicts": [ { "index": 1, "usable": true, "score": 55, "reason_ko": "광활한 숲의 모습은 있으나 강이 보이지 않고 계곡 지형의 깊이감이 부족합니다." }, { "index": 2, "usable": true, "score": 65, "reason_ko": "계곡 숲의 형태는 확인되지만 강이 뚜렷하게 나타나지 않아 다소 아쉽습니다." }, { "index": 3, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "숲 내부의 나무를 찍은 근경으로 광대한 계곡 지형을 전혀 보여주지 않습니다." }, { "index": 4, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "평탄한 숲 안쪽을 비추고 있어 넓은 계곡과 강의 구조를 파악할 수 없습니다." }, { "index": 5, "usable": true, "score": 90, "reason_ko": "강이 굽이쳐 흐르는 광대한 계곡 숲의 지형과 식생이 매우 명확하게 나타납니다." }, { "index": 6, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "쓰러진 나무 중심의 숲 내부 모습으로 전체적인 계곡 지형과는 무관합니다." } ], "chosen_index": 5, "chosen_reason_ko": "강이 가로지르는 광활한 펜실베이니아 계곡 숲의 전형적인 지형과 규모를 인위적인 요소 없이 명확하게 보여주어 가장 적합한 레퍼런스입니다." }, "gpt": { "verdicts": [ { "index": 1, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "산림 계곡 전경만 보이며 뿌리에 좁아진 광산 출구 구조는 전혀 확인되지 않는다." }, { "index": 2, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "넓은 산림 계곡을 보여 주지만 광산 출구나 그 구조적 형태가 없다." }, { "index": 3, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "숲 내부 사진일 뿐 뿌리로 협착된 광산 출구는 나타나지 않는다." }, { "index": 4, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "일반적인 숲 바닥과 나무만 보이고 광산 출구 구조는 없다." }, { "index": 5, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "펜실베이니아풍 산림 계곡과 강은 잘 보이지만 핵심 구조인 광산 출구가 전혀 없다." }, { "index": 6, "usable": false, "score": 0, "reason_ko": "쓰러진 나무가 있는 숲 내부로, 광산 출구나 뿌리에 의한 협착 형태를 읽을 수 없다." } ], "chosen_index": 0, "chosen_reason_ko": "후보 중 어느 사진도 핵심 구조인 뿌리에 좁아진 광산 출구를 보여 주지 않는다." } } }, "chosen": { "index": 5, "path": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/projects/37154490-a4ed-4b37-9092-489c054d8a72/images/c804efc3-0697-4c22-98b4-6992a70c2b20/structure_form_refs/bg_mine_complex/rounds/r003/cand_05.png", "sha256": "16b856258ab05330655f97de7e4bb8f3eddf0c0f64948faa7937927c61728fe3", "caption": null, "image_url": "https://assets.wfcdn.com/im/22045204/compr-r85/2822/282278993/Pennsylvania%2Bwilds.jpg", "source_website_url": "https://www.wayfair.co.uk/home-decor/pdp/alpen-home-pennsylvania-wilds-u110347831.html", "scores": { "gemini-pro": 90.0, "gpt": 0.0 }, "avg_score": 45.0, "usable": true, "reason_ko": "gemini-pro: 강이 굽이쳐 흐르는 광대한 계곡 숲의 지형과 식생이 매우 명확하게 나타납니다. / gpt: 펜실베이니아풍 산림 계곡과 강은 잘 보이지만 핵심 구조인 광산 출구가 전혀 없다." }, "pack_version": "13.202609050450" }, "group_fingerprint": "dbca8f6cc1babb42", "round_id": "r003", "path_kind": "round", "round_contract_version": 2, "ref_pack_version": "13.202609050450", "target_policy_version": "3-seed-parity", "form_ref_asset_id": "c2c33ace-7382-4f2f-8fe4-57e82307f9dc" } }, "mandatory_group_ids": [ "bg_mine_complex" ], "target": { "policy_version": "3-seed-parity", "pack_version": "13.202609050450", "universe_group_ids": [ "bg_mine_complex" ], "plate_bound_group_ids": [ "bg_mine_complex" ], "no_spec_group_ids": [] } }, "step_id": "outdoor_structure_form_reference", "run_id": "4537be4d-bbf2-41b7-a65b-322756be1098", "resolved_model": "gpt", "updated_at": "2026-09-04T19:43:17.458038+00:00", "project_config_snapshot": {} }