{
 "bg_animal_shelter": {
  "author_fp": "fe53b0c0dd3f57ee",
  "author": {
   "conformance_brief_en": "Every image shows the same one-storey, low horizontal, open-air animal-shelter kennel compound in coastal South Korea in 2026. Its slightly aged modern construction uses dull silver-gray galvanized steel-bar and wire-mesh boundary panels with localized oxidation, set on a light-gray concrete base beside a worn light-gray concrete service surface. One fixed galvanized steel access gate is the only emphasized opening in the enclosure boundary; it directly connects the dog confinement enclosure to the kennel-side service area running along the boundary's outside face. No additional prominent gates or openings are added. The compound stands within a believable, active working neighborhood with neighboring low-rise premises and an ordinary dark-gray asphalt access lane; it never appears isolated, abandoned, or prison-like.",
   "location_line_en": "A working animal-shelter kennel compound in a coastal South Korean neighborhood, 2026.",
   "variants": [
    {
     "approach_ko": "시나리오의 보호원 활동 공간과 갇힌 구역을 직접 시각화한 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "유기견 보호원",
      "갇혀있는 개들",
      "털깎고, 연고 바르고, 목욕시키고등",
      "여러 개의 철창과 울타리가 있는 다소 낡은 현대식 동물 보호 시설",
      "개들을 씻기고 관리하는 도구들이 놓인 실무적인 공간이다."
     ],
     "prompt_en": "An active animal-shelter site occupies an ordinary working neighborhood in coastal South Korea in 2026, bordered by neighboring low-rise service premises and a dark-gray asphalt access lane. The target structure is a one-storey, low horizontal, open-air kennel compound with a distinct dog confinement enclosure and an adjoining practical service area. The enclosure boundary consists of several slightly aged dull silver-gray galvanized steel-bar and wire-mesh panels on a light-gray concrete base, with minor oxidation and ordinary use wear. Exactly one fixed galvanized steel access gate is set into the boundary and opens directly to the kennel-side service area. The worn light-gray concrete service surface runs continuously along the outside face of the accessible boundary. The facility remains functional and maintained rather than abandoned, and its modest modern construction belongs naturally to the inhabited neighborhood.",
     "variant_id": "v1"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "주변 생활권에서 보호 시설로 좁혀 들어가는 장소 중심 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [],
     "prompt_en": "A lived-in coastal South Korean working neighborhood in 2026 surrounds the site, with ordinary neighboring low-rise premises and a dark-gray asphalt access lane. Within this setting stands one definite one-storey, low horizontal, open-air animal-shelter kennel compound. Its dog confinement enclosure is separated from the adjoining kennel-side service area by a boundary of dull silver-gray galvanized steel bars and wire mesh fixed to a light-gray concrete base. The modern metalwork is somewhat old, with restrained oxidation and repeated-use wear but no dereliction. A single fixed galvanized steel access gate forms the direct connection through the boundary. Outside that gate, the worn light-gray concrete service area extends alongside the accessible face of the enclosure. The whole facility reads as an ordinary functioning part of the neighborhood, not an isolated compound.",
     "variant_id": "v2"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "재료의 노후 상태와 고정 구조의 연결 관계를 우선한 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [],
     "prompt_en": "Dull silver-gray galvanized steel, light-gray concrete, and modest weathering define a functioning coastal South Korean animal shelter in 2026. The target is a one-storey, low and horizontal, open-air kennel compound whose enclosure boundary uses steel-bar and wire-mesh panels on a concrete base. Localized oxidation, faded galvanizing, and worn concrete show age while the site remains maintained and active. The dog confinement enclosure forms the inner kennel zone. Exactly one fixed galvanized steel access gate is built into its boundary and connects directly to the adjoining kennel-side service area. That service area has a worn light-gray concrete surface and runs along the outside face of the accessible boundary. The compound is embedded in an inhabited working neighborhood of neighboring low-rise premises beside an ordinary dark-gray asphalt lane, with regional everyday surroundings rather than empty ground.",
     "variant_id": "v3"
    }
   ]
  },
  "record": {
   "input_fingerprint": "bbbadded45cc5f99",
   "prompt": "SHARED CONFORMANCE BRIEF (invariant visual facts every candidate must satisfy):\n\nEvery image shows the same one-storey, low horizontal, open-air animal-shelter kennel compound in coastal South Korea in 2026. Its slightly aged modern construction uses dull silver-gray galvanized steel-bar and wire-mesh boundary panels with localized oxidation, set on a light-gray concrete base beside a worn light-gray concrete service surface. One fixed galvanized steel access gate is the only emphasized opening in the enclosure boundary; it directly connects the dog confinement enclosure to the kennel-side service area running along the boundary's outside face. No additional prominent gates or openings are added. The compound stands within a believable, active working neighborhood with neighboring low-rise premises and an ordinary dark-gray asphalt access lane; it never appears isolated, abandoned, or prison-like.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A working animal-shelter kennel compound in a coastal South Korean neighborhood, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nRottweiler and other sheltered dogs; Injection syringe; Ointment and movable grooming and bathing supplies",
   "roll_prompts": {
    "A": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nAn active animal-shelter site occupies an ordinary working neighborhood in coastal South Korea in 2026, bordered by neighboring low-rise service premises and a dark-gray asphalt access lane. The target structure is a one-storey, low horizontal, open-air kennel compound with a distinct dog confinement enclosure and an adjoining practical service area. The enclosure boundary consists of several slightly aged dull silver-gray galvanized steel-bar and wire-mesh panels on a light-gray concrete base, with minor oxidation and ordinary use wear. Exactly one fixed galvanized steel access gate is set into the boundary and opens directly to the kennel-side service area. The worn light-gray concrete service surface runs continuously along the outside face of the accessible boundary. The facility remains functional and maintained rather than abandoned, and its modest modern construction belongs naturally to the inhabited neighborhood.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A working animal-shelter kennel compound in a coastal South Korean neighborhood, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nRottweiler and other sheltered dogs; Injection syringe; Ointment and movable grooming and bathing supplies\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "B": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nA lived-in coastal South Korean working neighborhood in 2026 surrounds the site, with ordinary neighboring low-rise premises and a dark-gray asphalt access lane. Within this setting stands one definite one-storey, low horizontal, open-air animal-shelter kennel compound. Its dog confinement enclosure is separated from the adjoining kennel-side service area by a boundary of dull silver-gray galvanized steel bars and wire mesh fixed to a light-gray concrete base. The modern metalwork is somewhat old, with restrained oxidation and repeated-use wear but no dereliction. A single fixed galvanized steel access gate forms the direct connection through the boundary. Outside that gate, the worn light-gray concrete service area extends alongside the accessible face of the enclosure. The whole facility reads as an ordinary functioning part of the neighborhood, not an isolated compound.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A working animal-shelter kennel compound in a coastal South Korean neighborhood, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nRottweiler and other sheltered dogs; Injection syringe; Ointment and movable grooming and bathing supplies\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "C": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nDull silver-gray galvanized steel, light-gray concrete, and modest weathering define a functioning coastal South Korean animal shelter in 2026. The target is a one-storey, low and horizontal, open-air kennel compound whose enclosure boundary uses steel-bar and wire-mesh panels on a concrete base. Localized oxidation, faded galvanizing, and worn concrete show age while the site remains maintained and active. The dog confinement enclosure forms the inner kennel zone. Exactly one fixed galvanized steel access gate is built into its boundary and connects directly to the adjoining kennel-side service area. That service area has a worn light-gray concrete surface and runs along the outside face of the accessible boundary. The compound is embedded in an inhabited working neighborhood of neighboring low-rise premises beside an ordinary dark-gray asphalt lane, with regional everyday surroundings rather than empty ground.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A working animal-shelter kennel compound in a coastal South Korean neighborhood, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nRottweiler and other sheltered dogs; Injection syringe; Ointment and movable grooming and bathing supplies\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day."
   },
   "totals": {
    "C": 8,
    "B": 6,
    "A": 4
   },
   "selected": "C",
   "ranking": [
    "C",
    "B",
    "A"
   ],
   "verdicts": [
    {
     "label": "C",
     "score": 8,
     "verdict_ko": "브리프의 모든 요구사항(아연도금 강철 출입문, 콘크리트 서비스 구역, 회색 아스팔트 차선)을 충실히 반영하며 지역적 특성도 잘 살렸습니다."
    },
    {
     "label": "B",
     "score": 6,
     "verdict_ko": "아연도금 강철 문과 한국적인 배경은 훌륭하나, 지정된 '밝은 회색 콘크리트 서비스 표면'이 누락되고 문이 아스팔트로 직접 연결됩니다."
    },
    {
     "label": "A",
     "score": 4,
     "verdict_ko": "콘크리트 서비스 구역은 존재하나, 가장 강조된 출입문이 브리프에 명시된 '아연도금 강철'이 아닌 어두운 색상으로 칠해져 있어 지시를 어겼습니다."
    }
   ],
   "refs": [],
   "critique": {
    "issues": [
     {
      "issue_ko": "구조물 좌측을 덮고 있는 불투명한 금속 지붕과 단단한 벽면은 지침에 명시된 '야외(open-air) 견사 단지' 형태에 위배됩니다.",
      "fix_en": "Replace the solid metal roof and sheet-metal walls on the left half of the structure with the specified open-air steel-bar and wire-mesh panels."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "전면 출입문이 콘크리트 서비스 구역이 아닌 아스팔트 도로 방향으로 나 있어, 서비스 구역과 직접 연결되어야 한다는 지침과 어긋납니다.",
      "fix_en": "Move the mesh access gate from the front boundary to the side boundary so it directly connects the inner enclosure to the concrete service area on the right."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "전경 우측 바닥에 놓인 호스 릴과 양동이들은 제외 대상으로 지정된 '이동식 목욕 용품'에 해당합니다.",
      "fix_en": "Remove the hose reel, buckets, and scrub brush from the foreground service area."
     }
    ]
   },
   "fix_prompt": "Edit this photograph. Apply ONLY the corrections listed below,\neach in place, changing nothing else:\n\nCORRECTIONS:\n- Replace the solid metal roof and sheet-metal walls on the left half of the structure with the specified open-air steel-bar and wire-mesh panels.\n- Move the mesh access gate from the front boundary to the side boundary so it directly connects the inner enclosure to the concrete service area on the right.\n- Remove the hose reel, buckets, and scrub brush from the foreground service area.\n\nPRESERVE EVERYTHING ELSE EXACTLY as in the original photograph —\nevery person, pose, face, garment, object, set feature, lighting,\ncamera and framing stay identical. No text, captions or\nwatermarks anywhere."
  }
 },
 "bg_fishing_boat": {
  "author_fp": "3b717e5fcdf846ae",
  "author": {
   "conformance_brief_en": "Every image shows the same compact, low-profile South Korean small fishing vessel in 2026: one working deck and one storey only, with no upper cabin. Its white fiberglass-reinforced-plastic hull has a dark navy antifouling lower section; the open deck is sea-green non-slip fiberglass; the attached white fiberglass wheelhouse has faded medium-blue trim, dark gray glazing in plain aluminum frames, and exactly one evidenced deck-facing entrance with a blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding door. The forward bow lies beyond the main exterior deck, while the wheelhouse directly adjoins the deck and its single entrance provides the continuous route inside. Salt chalking, streaking, chipped trim, ordinary ropes, and fishing gear show regular working use. The vessel is moored at a pale-gray concrete quay within an active, currently inhabited coastal fishing-harbor neighborhood of low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete buildings, muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds, and a narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road. No prominent additional opening may alter the vessel topology.",
   "location_line_en": "A contemporary small fishing vessel in a lived-in working harbor on the coast of South Korea, 2026.",
   "variants": [
    {
     "approach_ko": "시나리오의 갑판·뱃머리·조타실 동선을 직접 시각화한 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "바다위에 떠있는 소형어선.",
      "갑판에 홀로 앉아있다.",
      "인우, 발작적으로 일어나 조타실로 달려가 뱃머리를 돌리려 한다.",
      "수리영, 조타실로 따라들어가 막으면서"
     ],
     "prompt_en": "An active, currently inhabited fishing-harbor neighborhood on the South Korean coast surrounds a pale-gray concrete quay in 2026. Low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete waterfront buildings and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds line a narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road. The main subject is a moored, compact, low-profile small fishing vessel with one working deck and a one-storey wheelhouse, with no upper cabin. Its fiberglass-reinforced-plastic hull is white above a dark navy antifouling lower section. The primary open deck is sea-green non-slip fiberglass with salt-roughened surfaces, ordinary ropes, and fishing gear. The bow forms the forward end beyond this deck. A white fiberglass wheelhouse with faded medium-blue trim directly adjoins the deck. Dark gray wheelhouse glazing sits in plain aluminum frames. Exactly one blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding entrance faces the deck at their junction and provides the direct route into the wheelhouse. Salt chalking, streaks, and chipped trim show regular working use rather than abandonment.",
     "variant_id": "v1"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "항구 동네에서 선박으로 좁혀 들어가는 장소 우선 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "현대식 소형 어선의 외부 갑판 공간.",
      "바다의 습기와 염분이 묻어나는 거친 표면과 밧줄, 어구들이 흩어져 있다.",
      "갑판에 홀로 앉아있다.",
      "조타실로 따라들어가"
     ],
     "prompt_en": "This is a lived-in coastal South Korean fishing district in 2026, with an active working harbor rather than an isolated or abandoned site. A narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road passes low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete harbor buildings and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds beside a pale-gray concrete quay. A compact small fishing vessel moored at the quay is the main subject. It has one working deck, one storey, and no upper cabin, forming a low practical mass. The hull is white fiberglass-reinforced plastic with a dark navy antifouling lower section. Its sea-green non-slip fiberglass deck is the main open area and carries ordinary ropes and fishing gear across a salt-roughened working surface. The bow continues forward beyond the deck. The adjoining wheelhouse is white fiberglass with faded medium-blue trim and dark gray glazing in plain aluminum frames. At the deck-wheelhouse junction, exactly one deck-facing entrance has a blue-painted aluminum frame and sliding door, creating the direct passage from the exterior deck into the wheelhouse. Chalking, salt streaks, and chipped blue trim are consistent with maintained daily use.",
     "variant_id": "v2"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "재료와 어선 유형을 먼저 고정하는 물성 중심 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "소형어선",
      "뱃머리를 돌리려 한다.",
      "조타실로 달려가",
      "바다의 습기와 염분이 묻어나는 거친 표면과 밧줄, 어구들이 흩어져 있다."
     ],
     "prompt_en": "A contemporary working harbor on the coast of South Korea contains an ordinary, currently inhabited waterfront neighborhood in 2026. Its narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road, pale-gray concrete quay, low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete buildings, and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds form the vessel's real everyday setting. The main structure is a definite one-storey, single-working-deck fishing vessel with compact low-profile massing and no upper cabin. The hull shell is white fiberglass-reinforced plastic over a dark navy antifouling lower section. The broad open deck has a sea-green non-slip fiberglass finish, visibly roughened by moisture and salt, with ordinary working ropes and fishing gear. The bow occupies the forward end beyond the deck. A single-storey white fiberglass wheelhouse with faded medium-blue trim is attached directly to the deck. Its exterior glazing is dark gray in plain aluminum frames. Exactly one blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding entrance faces the deck at the junction with the wheelhouse, preserving a direct continuous route between them. Faded color, surface chalking, salt streaks, and chipped trim indicate sustained working use without dereliction.",
     "variant_id": "v3"
    }
   ]
  },
  "record": {
   "input_fingerprint": "09b3dd95e6e86ced",
   "prompt": "SHARED CONFORMANCE BRIEF (invariant visual facts every candidate must satisfy):\n\nEvery image shows the same compact, low-profile South Korean small fishing vessel in 2026: one working deck and one storey only, with no upper cabin. Its white fiberglass-reinforced-plastic hull has a dark navy antifouling lower section; the open deck is sea-green non-slip fiberglass; the attached white fiberglass wheelhouse has faded medium-blue trim, dark gray glazing in plain aluminum frames, and exactly one evidenced deck-facing entrance with a blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding door. The forward bow lies beyond the main exterior deck, while the wheelhouse directly adjoins the deck and its single entrance provides the continuous route inside. Salt chalking, streaking, chipped trim, ordinary ropes, and fishing gear show regular working use. The vessel is moored at a pale-gray concrete quay within an active, currently inhabited coastal fishing-harbor neighborhood of low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete buildings, muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds, and a narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road. No prominent additional opening may alter the vessel topology.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A contemporary small fishing vessel in a lived-in working harbor on the coast of South Korea, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nhandheld map; old photograph; vessel position at sea; dusk condition",
   "roll_prompts": {
    "A": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nAn active, currently inhabited fishing-harbor neighborhood on the South Korean coast surrounds a pale-gray concrete quay in 2026. Low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete waterfront buildings and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds line a narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road. The main subject is a moored, compact, low-profile small fishing vessel with one working deck and a one-storey wheelhouse, with no upper cabin. Its fiberglass-reinforced-plastic hull is white above a dark navy antifouling lower section. The primary open deck is sea-green non-slip fiberglass with salt-roughened surfaces, ordinary ropes, and fishing gear. The bow forms the forward end beyond this deck. A white fiberglass wheelhouse with faded medium-blue trim directly adjoins the deck. Dark gray wheelhouse glazing sits in plain aluminum frames. Exactly one blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding entrance faces the deck at their junction and provides the direct route into the wheelhouse. Salt chalking, streaks, and chipped trim show regular working use rather than abandonment.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A contemporary small fishing vessel in a lived-in working harbor on the coast of South Korea, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nhandheld map; old photograph; vessel position at sea; dusk condition\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "B": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nThis is a lived-in coastal South Korean fishing district in 2026, with an active working harbor rather than an isolated or abandoned site. A narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road passes low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete harbor buildings and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds beside a pale-gray concrete quay. A compact small fishing vessel moored at the quay is the main subject. It has one working deck, one storey, and no upper cabin, forming a low practical mass. The hull is white fiberglass-reinforced plastic with a dark navy antifouling lower section. Its sea-green non-slip fiberglass deck is the main open area and carries ordinary ropes and fishing gear across a salt-roughened working surface. The bow continues forward beyond the deck. The adjoining wheelhouse is white fiberglass with faded medium-blue trim and dark gray glazing in plain aluminum frames. At the deck-wheelhouse junction, exactly one deck-facing entrance has a blue-painted aluminum frame and sliding door, creating the direct passage from the exterior deck into the wheelhouse. Chalking, salt streaks, and chipped blue trim are consistent with maintained daily use.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A contemporary small fishing vessel in a lived-in working harbor on the coast of South Korea, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nhandheld map; old photograph; vessel position at sea; dusk condition\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "C": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nA contemporary working harbor on the coast of South Korea contains an ordinary, currently inhabited waterfront neighborhood in 2026. Its narrow dark-gray asphalt quay road, pale-gray concrete quay, low-rise off-white and pale-gray reinforced-concrete buildings, and muted blue-gray corrugated-metal work sheds form the vessel's real everyday setting. The main structure is a definite one-storey, single-working-deck fishing vessel with compact low-profile massing and no upper cabin. The hull shell is white fiberglass-reinforced plastic over a dark navy antifouling lower section. The broad open deck has a sea-green non-slip fiberglass finish, visibly roughened by moisture and salt, with ordinary working ropes and fishing gear. The bow occupies the forward end beyond the deck. A single-storey white fiberglass wheelhouse with faded medium-blue trim is attached directly to the deck. Its exterior glazing is dark gray in plain aluminum frames. Exactly one blue-painted aluminum-framed sliding entrance faces the deck at the junction with the wheelhouse, preserving a direct continuous route between them. Faded color, surface chalking, salt streaks, and chipped trim indicate sustained working use without dereliction.\n\nTHE LOCATION: A contemporary small fishing vessel in a lived-in working harbor on the coast of South Korea, 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nhandheld map; old photograph; vessel position at sea; dusk condition\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day."
   },
   "totals": {
    "A": 7,
    "B": 3,
    "C": 4
   },
   "selected": "A",
   "ranking": [
    "A",
    "C",
    "B"
   ],
   "verdicts": [
    {
     "label": "A",
     "score": 7,
     "verdict_ko": "Matches the brief closely, featuring the required dark gray glazing, a single deck-facing blue sliding door, and correct neighborhood context with muted blue-gray sheds."
    },
    {
     "label": "B",
     "score": 3,
     "verdict_ko": "Fails the glazing constraint by showing clear/transparent windows instead of dark gray, and the background sheds appear as one massive warehouse rather than muted sheds."
    },
    {
     "label": "C",
     "score": 4,
     "verdict_ko": "Violates the entrance placement by locating the sliding door on the port side facing the quay rather than facing the main exterior deck, and features transparent glazing."
    }
   ],
   "refs": [],
   "critique": {
    "issues": [
     {
      "issue_ko": "파란색 미닫이 출입문이 갑판을 향하지 않고 조타실 측면에 위치해 있습니다.",
      "fix_en": "Move the blue sliding entrance from the side wall of the wheelhouse to the wall that directly faces the open deck."
     }
    ]
   },
   "fix_prompt": "Edit this photograph. Apply ONLY the corrections listed below,\neach in place, changing nothing else:\n\nCORRECTIONS:\n- Move the blue sliding entrance from the side wall of the wheelhouse to the wall that directly faces the open deck.\n\nPRESERVE EVERYTHING ELSE EXACTLY as in the original photograph —\nevery person, pose, face, garment, object, set feature, lighting,\ncamera and framing stay identical. No text, captions or\nwatermarks anywhere."
  }
 },
 "bg_villa_rooftop_unit": {
  "author_fp": "1ef51b54eb25a64b",
  "author": {
   "conformance_brief_en": "Every image must show the same aging three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete villa with red-brown face-brick walls, a flat roof, and a compact single-storey rooftop room finished in weathered light-gray cement render. The rooftop room has exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door near the stair arrival and one silver aluminum-framed exterior window facing another accessible part of the roof. A single dark green painted steel ground-level entrance door connects the alley to a shaded gray concrete yard. One narrow reinforced-concrete exterior stair with dull gray painted steel railings climbs along the villa from that yard to the roof. The surrounding rough gray concrete rooftop has worn green urethane waterproofing at joints, one aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank near the room, and one gray concrete wall beside the room. The complete alley-to-door-to-yard-to-stair-to-rooftop route must remain legible. The villa must stand among adjacent low-rise residential buildings in a believable, currently inhabited Incheon-outskirts neighborhood.",
   "location_line_en": "An aging multifamily villa and rooftop room in an inhabited residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon, coastal South Korea, in 2026.",
   "variants": [
    {
     "approach_ko": "시나리오의 공간 동선을 직접 시각화한 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "인천 변두리",
      "오래된 빌라 옥탑방 전경",
      "옥탑방 옥상. 물탱크.",
      "옥탑방 철문 현관",
      "창문",
      "다세대 빌라 문",
      "마당 후미진 곳",
      "옥탑방과 연결되는 계단"
     ],
     "prompt_en": "An inhabited low-rise residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon surrounds the site, with adjacent aging villas close to the gray asphalt lane. The target is a three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete multifamily villa clad in weathered red-brown face brick, with a flat roof and a compact single-storey rooftop room. One dark green painted steel entrance door leads from the alley into a shaded gray concrete yard adjoining the building. A narrow aging reinforced-concrete exterior stair with dull gray painted steel railings climbs along the villa from the yard to the roof. The rooftop surface is rough gray concrete with worn green urethane waterproofing at joints. The rooftop room has weathered light-gray cement-rendered walls, exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door opening onto the roof near the stair arrival, and exactly one silver aluminum-framed window facing another accessible part of the roof. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank stands near the room, and one gray concrete wall borders the roof beside it. The alley, entrance, yard, stair, roof, and rooftop room form one continuous permanent route.",
     "variant_id": "v1"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "인천 변두리 주거 골목에서 출발하는 지역 맥락 중심 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "인천 변두리 부감",
      "오래된 빌라 옥탑방 전경",
      "다세대 빌라 문",
      "옥탑방과 연결되는 계단"
     ],
     "prompt_en": "The site belongs to a dense, currently inhabited working residential neighborhood on the Incheon outskirts. Aging low-rise villas with subdued red-brown brick and pale cement-rendered finishes line a narrow gray asphalt alley around the target. The target villa is a definite three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete block with weathered red-brown face-brick walls and a flat roof. A single dark green painted steel entrance door separates the alley from the shaded gray concrete ground-level yard. The yard meets the building and the base of one narrow reinforced-concrete exterior stair, whose dull gray painted steel railings follow the stair up the villa to the roof. A compact single-storey rooftop room stands on the rough gray concrete roof, which retains worn green urethane waterproofing along joints. Its weathered light-gray cement-rendered exterior contains exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door beside the stair arrival and exactly one silver aluminum-framed window toward another accessible roof area. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank occupies the roof near the room. One gray concrete wall borders the rooftop beside the room. The rooftop surface surrounds all of these elements and completes the route from the alley through the yard.",
     "variant_id": "v2"
    },
    {
     "approach_ko": "노후 재료와 표면의 실제성을 우선한 물성 중심 접근",
     "evidence_ko": [
      "오래된 빌라 옥탑방 전경",
      "옥탑방 옥상. 물탱크.",
      "옥탑방 철문 현관",
      "마당 후미진 곳",
      "옥탑방과 연결되는 계단"
     ],
     "prompt_en": "Weathered red-brown face brick, exposed gray concrete, faded paint, and localized coastal grime define an ordinary inhabited Incheon-outskirts villa site in 2026. Adjacent low-rise residential buildings enclose the narrow gray asphalt alley and establish a continuous working neighborhood. The target is a three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete villa with red-brown face-brick exterior walls and a flat roof. Its one ground-level alley entrance is a dark green painted steel door opening into a shaded gray concrete yard. From this yard, one narrow aging reinforced-concrete stair with dull gray painted steel railings rises along the building to the roof. The rooftop is rough gray concrete with worn green urethane waterproofing at seams and joints. A compact single-storey rooftop room is finished in cracked and weather-stained light-gray cement render. It has exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door on the roof near the stair arrival and exactly one silver aluminum-framed exterior window on another face toward an accessible portion of the rooftop. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank stands near the room. One plain gray concrete wall borders the rooftop beside it. The roof surrounds the room and receives the stair, preserving the direct route from alley to entrance, yard, stair, and rooftop.",
     "variant_id": "v3"
    }
   ]
  },
  "record": {
   "input_fingerprint": "0e712bbca9d53619",
   "prompt": "SHARED CONFORMANCE BRIEF (invariant visual facts every candidate must satisfy):\n\nEvery image must show the same aging three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete villa with red-brown face-brick walls, a flat roof, and a compact single-storey rooftop room finished in weathered light-gray cement render. The rooftop room has exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door near the stair arrival and one silver aluminum-framed exterior window facing another accessible part of the roof. A single dark green painted steel ground-level entrance door connects the alley to a shaded gray concrete yard. One narrow reinforced-concrete exterior stair with dull gray painted steel railings climbs along the villa from that yard to the roof. The surrounding rough gray concrete rooftop has worn green urethane waterproofing at joints, one aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank near the room, and one gray concrete wall beside the room. The complete alley-to-door-to-yard-to-stair-to-rooftop route must remain legible. The villa must stand among adjacent low-rise residential buildings in a believable, currently inhabited Incheon-outskirts neighborhood.\n\nTHE LOCATION: An aging multifamily villa and rooftop room in an inhabited residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon, coastal South Korea, in 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nclothesline; wooden platform; dried acorus leaves; advertising flyer; bicycle; arriving vehicle; half-open state of the iron entrance door; illuminated state of the rooftop room; cast human shadows; black cat",
   "roll_prompts": {
    "A": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nAn inhabited low-rise residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon surrounds the site, with adjacent aging villas close to the gray asphalt lane. The target is a three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete multifamily villa clad in weathered red-brown face brick, with a flat roof and a compact single-storey rooftop room. One dark green painted steel entrance door leads from the alley into a shaded gray concrete yard adjoining the building. A narrow aging reinforced-concrete exterior stair with dull gray painted steel railings climbs along the villa from the yard to the roof. The rooftop surface is rough gray concrete with worn green urethane waterproofing at joints. The rooftop room has weathered light-gray cement-rendered walls, exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door opening onto the roof near the stair arrival, and exactly one silver aluminum-framed window facing another accessible part of the roof. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank stands near the room, and one gray concrete wall borders the roof beside it. The alley, entrance, yard, stair, roof, and rooftop room form one continuous permanent route.\n\nTHE LOCATION: An aging multifamily villa and rooftop room in an inhabited residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon, coastal South Korea, in 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nclothesline; wooden platform; dried acorus leaves; advertising flyer; bicycle; arriving vehicle; half-open state of the iron entrance door; illuminated state of the rooftop room; cast human shadows; black cat\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "B": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nThe site belongs to a dense, currently inhabited working residential neighborhood on the Incheon outskirts. Aging low-rise villas with subdued red-brown brick and pale cement-rendered finishes line a narrow gray asphalt alley around the target. The target villa is a definite three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete block with weathered red-brown face-brick walls and a flat roof. A single dark green painted steel entrance door separates the alley from the shaded gray concrete ground-level yard. The yard meets the building and the base of one narrow reinforced-concrete exterior stair, whose dull gray painted steel railings follow the stair up the villa to the roof. A compact single-storey rooftop room stands on the rough gray concrete roof, which retains worn green urethane waterproofing along joints. Its weathered light-gray cement-rendered exterior contains exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door beside the stair arrival and exactly one silver aluminum-framed window toward another accessible roof area. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank occupies the roof near the room. One gray concrete wall borders the rooftop beside the room. The rooftop surface surrounds all of these elements and completes the route from the alley through the yard.\n\nTHE LOCATION: An aging multifamily villa and rooftop room in an inhabited residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon, coastal South Korea, in 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nclothesline; wooden platform; dried acorus leaves; advertising flyer; bicycle; arriving vehicle; half-open state of the iron entrance door; illuminated state of the rooftop room; cast human shadows; black cat\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day.",
    "C": "A location-scouting photograph for a live-action film — a real place,\nfound and chosen for shooting. The TARGET STRUCTURE described below is\nthe main subject, photographed from a slightly elevated three-quarter\nview that shows its overall shape, faces and openings, and it stands\ninside its real, lived-in neighborhood: the adjacent buildings, the\nalley or street it belongs to, and the everyday surroundings such a\nplace naturally has. Never an isolated building on empty ground. This\nimage becomes the look authority (seed) for every later view of the\nSAME structure, so render the exterior complete and real: no cutaway,\nno floor-plan or room labels, no transparent enclosed surfaces, never\na drawing or diagram. Real materials, real weathering, and the\nordinary visual texture of a place where people actually live.\n\nWeathered red-brown face brick, exposed gray concrete, faded paint, and localized coastal grime define an ordinary inhabited Incheon-outskirts villa site in 2026. Adjacent low-rise residential buildings enclose the narrow gray asphalt alley and establish a continuous working neighborhood. The target is a three-storey rectangular reinforced-concrete villa with red-brown face-brick exterior walls and a flat roof. Its one ground-level alley entrance is a dark green painted steel door opening into a shaded gray concrete yard. From this yard, one narrow aging reinforced-concrete stair with dull gray painted steel railings rises along the building to the roof. The rooftop is rough gray concrete with worn green urethane waterproofing at seams and joints. A compact single-storey rooftop room is finished in cracked and weather-stained light-gray cement render. It has exactly one dark green painted steel entrance door on the roof near the stair arrival and exactly one silver aluminum-framed exterior window on another face toward an accessible portion of the rooftop. One aging cylindrical stainless-steel water tank stands near the room. One plain gray concrete wall borders the rooftop beside it. The roof surrounds the room and receives the stair, preserving the direct route from alley to entrance, yard, stair, and rooftop.\n\nTHE LOCATION: An aging multifamily villa and rooftop room in an inhabited residential alley on the outskirts of Incheon, coastal South Korea, in 2026.\n\nSCENE TRANSIENTS — the items below belong to specific scripted\nmoments, not to the permanent place. Do not reproduce these particular\nstaged items or momentary states. This does not forbid the ordinary,\ngeneric equivalents such a neighborhood would naturally show:\nclothesline; wooden platform; dried acorus leaves; advertising flyer; bicycle; arriving vehicle; half-open state of the iron entrance door; illuminated state of the rooftop room; cast human shadows; black cat\n\nCLEAN PLATE RULES: no people and no animals anywhere in frame. Do not\nstage any scripted moment — no doors held open for a scene, no\ninterior lights implying someone mid-scene, no picture vehicles or\nprops arranged for action. Generic, everyday signs of habitation that\nany such neighborhood would naturally show are welcome — leave their\nselection to the image itself, exactly as a scout would find the\nplace on an ordinary day."
   },
   "totals": {
    "A": 7,
    "B": 5,
    "C": 3
   },
   "selected": "A",
   "ranking": [
    "A",
    "B",
    "C"
   ],
   "verdicts": [
    {
     "label": "A",
     "score": 7,
     "verdict_ko": "Accurate three-storey villa and rooftop layout with a legible route. Minor deviation: the alley entrance is a double gate rather than a single door."
    },
    {
     "label": "B",
     "score": 5,
     "verdict_ko": "Violates brief conformance by depicting a two-storey building instead of three. The rooftop room incorrectly places the door and window on the same wall."
    },
    {
     "label": "C",
     "score": 3,
     "verdict_ko": "Hard violation: The exterior staircase features physically impossible geometry with disconnected steps and a suspended landing."
    }
   ],
   "refs": [],
   "critique": {
    "issues": [
     {
      "issue_ko": "빌라 건물이 지시된 3층이 아닌 2층으로 묘사되어 있습니다.",
      "fix_en": "Add a third storey to the main block of the villa below the roof."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "마당과 골목을 연결하는 입구가 단일 출입문이 아닌 양개형 대문(이중문)으로 묘사되어 있습니다.",
      "fix_en": "Replace the double gate at the yard entrance with a single entrance door."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "배제해야 할 일시적 요소(Scene Transients)인 자전거가 골목에 배치되어 있습니다.",
      "fix_en": "Remove all bicycles parked in the alleys."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "배제해야 할 일시적 요소인 빨랫줄과 빨래가 주변 건물 옥상에 나타나 있습니다.",
      "fix_en": "Remove the clotheslines and hanging laundry from the adjacent rooftops."
     },
     {
      "issue_ko": "외부 계단의 난간이 무광 회색 도색 강철이 아닌 광택이 나는 은색 스테인리스 스틸 재질로 보입니다.",
      "fix_en": "Change the material of the exterior stair railings to dull gray painted steel."
     }
    ]
   },
   "fix_prompt": "Edit this photograph. Apply ONLY the corrections listed below,\neach in place, changing nothing else:\n\nCORRECTIONS:\n- Add a third storey to the main block of the villa below the roof.\n- Replace the double gate at the yard entrance with a single entrance door.\n- Remove all bicycles parked in the alleys.\n- Remove the clotheslines and hanging laundry from the adjacent rooftops.\n- Change the material of the exterior stair railings to dull gray painted steel.\n\nPRESERVE EVERYTHING ELSE EXACTLY as in the original photograph —\nevery person, pose, face, garment, object, set feature, lighting,\ncamera and framing stay identical. No text, captions or\nwatermarks anywhere."
  }
 }
}