stage: w16_floor_plan_grid_layout_slice | run_status: validation_failed | exit_code: 1 | model: gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview | derived_from(W15e): 20260526_0657_1c143d | image_api_call_count: 0
layout_rationale:
The layout structures the apartment with a clear separation between the communal day-use areas on the west side and the completely segregated, enclosed night-use rooms on the east. The open-plan combination of the entry alcove, living zone, and kitchen nook allows for spatial flow and cross-ventilation, terminating at sliding windows on opposing east/west walls. The primary bedroom and secondary bedroom are distinct spatial units occupying the southeast and northeast corners, satisfying the requirement for standalone enclosures while maximizing privacy from the main living spaces.
| unit_id | unit_kind | enclosure_mode | scale_hint | rects | open_to | door_to |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| living_dining | living_zone | open_zone_inside_plan | primary_zone | [{"x": 0, "y": 3, "w": 4, "h": 5}, {"x": 4, "y": 0, "w": 2, "h": 8}] | kitchen_nook, entry_alcove | private_bedroom_a, private_bedroom_b |
| kitchen_nook | kitchen_zone | open_zone_inside_plan | compact_nook_or_wall_run | [{"x": 0, "y": 0, "w": 4, "h": 3}] | living_dining | |
| private_bedroom_a | private_room | full_wall_enclosed_room | primary_zone | [{"x": 6, "y": 5, "w": 4, "h": 5}] | living_dining | |
| private_bedroom_b | private_room | full_wall_enclosed_room | primary_zone | [{"x": 6, "y": 0, "w": 4, "h": 5}] | living_dining | |
| bathroom | service_room | full_wall_enclosed_room | compact_service_cell | [{"x": 3, "y": 8, "w": 3, "h": 2}] | entry_alcove | |
| entry_alcove | entry_transition | interior_threshold | compact_nook_or_wall_run | [{"x": 0, "y": 8, "w": 3, "h": 2}] | living_dining | bathroom |
| number | unit_id | cell | render_mode |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | living_dining | [3, 5] | area_marker |
| #2 | kitchen_nook | [2, 1] | area_marker |
| #3 | private_bedroom_a | [8, 7] | area_marker |
| #4 | private_bedroom_b | [8, 2] | area_marker |
| #5 | bathroom | [4, 9] | area_marker |
| #6 | entry_alcove | [1, 9] | area_marker |
| #7 | entry_alcove | [1, 10] | opening_marker |
| #8 | private_bedroom_a | [6, 6] | opening_marker |
| #9 | private_bedroom_b | [6, 3] | opening_marker |
| #10 | bathroom | [3, 9] | opening_marker |
| #11 | living_dining | [0, 5] | opening_marker |
| #12 | private_bedroom_a | [10, 7] | opening_marker |
| #13 | living_dining | [3, 5] | furniture_symbol |
| #14 | kitchen_nook | [2, 0] | furniture_symbol |
| #15 | private_bedroom_a | [8, 5] | furniture_symbol |
| #16 | private_bedroom_b | [8, 0] | furniture_symbol |
| #17 | living_dining | [5, 0] | furniture_symbol |
| #18 | private_bedroom_a | [9, 7] | floor_marker |
| #19 | private_bedroom_a | [7, 6] | floor_marker |
| #20 | private_bedroom_a | [8, 5] | wall_marker |
| #21 | bathroom | [4, 8] | wall_marker |
| #22 | living_dining | [2, 5] | furniture_symbol |
| #23 | private_bedroom_a | [7, 5] | floor_marker |
| invariant | status | detail |
|---|---|---|
| inputs_present | PASS | {"missing_inputs": [], "topology_brief_present": true, "candidate_present": true, "grid_layout_present": true, "grid_layout_fp_count": 1, "stage_status": "reused", "prev_run_id": "20260526_0657_1c143d"} |
| target_fp_only_fp_l05_01 | PASS | {"received_target_fp_ids": ["fp_l05_01"], "allowed": ["fp_l05_01"]} |
| model_is_gpt_5_5_when_generated | FAIL | {"model_used": "gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview", "required": "gpt-5.5", "stage_status": "reused"} |
| grid_is_10x10_and_all_rects_in_bounds | PASS | {"failures": [], "failure_count": 0, "grid_cols": 10, "grid_rows": 10} |
| unit_ids_exist_in_w15_topology | PASS | {"failures": [], "failure_count": 0} |
| fixtures_reference_candidate_numbers_and_units | PASS | {"failures": [], "failure_count": 0} |
| declared_open_or_door_adjacency_has_touching_or_nearby_grid_relation | PASS | {"failures": [], "failure_count": 0} |
| svg_render_emitted_and_no_image_api_call | PASS | {"svg_emitted": true, "image_api_call_count": 0} |
| scale_hint_cell_budget | FAIL | {"failures": [{"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "kitchen_nook", "reason": "exceeds_max_cells", "scale_hint": "compact_nook_or_wall_run", "cell_count": 12, "max_cells": 4}, {"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "kitchen_nook", "reason": "shape_not_one_axis_thin", "scale_hint": "compact_nook_or_wall_run", "rects": [{"x": 0, "y": 0, "w": 4, "h": 3}]}, {"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "private_bedroom_a", "reason": "below_min_cells", "scale_hint": "primary_zone", "cell_count": 20, "min_cells": 25}, {"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "private_bedroom_b", "reason": "below_min_cells", "scale_hint": "prim |
| total_occupied_cells_in_bound | FAIL | {"failures": [{"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unique_cells": 100, "min": 55, "max": 75}], "unique_cells": 100, "per_fp_unique_cells": {"fp_l05_01": 100}, "min": 55, "max": 75} |
| private_room_primary_zone_disallowed | FAIL | {"failures": [{"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "private_bedroom_a", "unit_kind": "private_room", "scale_hint": "primary_zone"}, {"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "unit_id": "private_bedroom_b", "unit_kind": "private_room", "scale_hint": "primary_zone"}], "failure_count": 2} |
| unit_rects_do_not_overlap | PASS | {"failures": [], "failure_count": 0} |
| fixture_cells_inside_declared_unit_rects | FAIL | {"failures": [{"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "fixture_number": 7, "unit_id": "entry_alcove", "cell": [1, 10], "reason": "cell_outside_unit_rects"}, {"fp_id": "fp_l05_01", "fixture_number": 12, "unit_id": "private_bedroom_a", "cell": [10, 7], "reason": "cell_outside_unit_rects"}], "failure_count": 2} |
| svg_is_well_formed_xml | PASS | {"svg_count": 1, "failures": [], "failure_count": 0} |
| production_diff_zero_db_write_zero_image_api_call_zero | PASS | {"production_diff_empty": true, "db_write_count": 0, "image_import_seen": false, "image_api_call_count": 0} |
{
"run_id": "20260526_0950_c9f674",
"stage": "w16_floor_plan_grid_layout_slice",
"plan_version": "bps_w1",
"generated_at": "2026-05-26T09:50:15.945660+09:00",
"args": {
"derive_grid_layout_from": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/scripts_output/floor_plan_topology_slice_experiment/20260526_0657_1c143d",
"reuse_grid_from": "scripts_output/floor_plan_grid_layout_model_compare_slice_experiment/20260526_0934_92491e",
"target_fp_ids": "fp_l05_01",
"generate": false,
"model": "gpt-5.5",
"output_root": "/Users/manta/Documents/Projects/TheRoad-I1/scripts_output/floor_plan_grid_layout_slice_experiment",
"diag_print_imports": false
},
"derived_from": "20260526_0657_1c143d",
"target_fp_ids": [
"fp_l05_01"
],
"invalid_targets": [],
"model_used": "gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview",
"image_api_call_count": 0,
"image_generation_count": 0,
"outputs": [
"grid_layout_plan.json",
"grid_layout_compatibility_report.json"
],
"run_status": "validation_failed",
"exit_code": 1,
"failed_invariants": [
"model_is_gpt_5_5_when_generated",
"scale_hint_cell_budget",
"total_occupied_cells_in_bound",
"private_room_primary_zone_disallowed",
"fixture_cells_inside_declared_unit_rects"
],
"stage_status": "reused",
"reused_grid_from": "20260526_0934_92491e",
"reused_prior_model": "gemini/gemini-3.1-pro-preview"
}{
"grid_layout_by_fp": {
"fp_l05_01": {
"grid": {
"cols": 10,
"rows": 10
},
"outer_outline": [
{
"x": 0,
"y": 0,
"w": 10,
"h": 10
}
],
"units": [
{
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"unit_kind": "living_zone",
"enclosure_mode": "open_zone_inside_plan",
"rects": [
{
"x": 0,
"y": 3,
"w": 4,
"h": 5
},
{
"x": 4,
"y": 0,
"w": 2,
"h": 8
}
],
"open_to": [
"kitchen_nook",
"entry_alcove"
],
"door_to": [
"private_bedroom_a",
"private_bedroom_b"
],
"scale_hint": "primary_zone",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:5",
"scene:12"
]
},
{
"unit_id": "kitchen_nook",
"unit_kind": "kitchen_zone",
"enclosure_mode": "open_zone_inside_plan",
"rects": [
{
"x": 0,
"y": 0,
"w": 4,
"h": 3
}
],
"open_to": [
"living_dining"
],
"door_to": [],
"scale_hint": "compact_nook_or_wall_run",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:5"
]
},
{
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"unit_kind": "private_room",
"enclosure_mode": "full_wall_enclosed_room",
"rects": [
{
"x": 6,
"y": 5,
"w": 4,
"h": 5
}
],
"open_to": [],
"door_to": [
"living_dining"
],
"scale_hint": "primary_zone",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:12",
"scene:14"
]
},
{
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_b",
"unit_kind": "private_room",
"enclosure_mode": "full_wall_enclosed_room",
"rects": [
{
"x": 6,
"y": 0,
"w": 4,
"h": 5
}
],
"open_to": [],
"door_to": [
"living_dining"
],
"scale_hint": "primary_zone",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:12",
"scene:18"
]
},
{
"unit_id": "bathroom",
"unit_kind": "service_room",
"enclosure_mode": "full_wall_enclosed_room",
"rects": [
{
"x": 3,
"y": 8,
"w": 3,
"h": 2
}
],
"open_to": [],
"door_to": [
"entry_alcove"
],
"scale_hint": "compact_service_cell",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:18"
]
},
{
"unit_id": "entry_alcove",
"unit_kind": "entry_transition",
"enclosure_mode": "interior_threshold",
"rects": [
{
"x": 0,
"y": 8,
"w": 3,
"h": 2
}
],
"open_to": [
"living_dining"
],
"door_to": [
"bathroom"
],
"scale_hint": "compact_nook_or_wall_run",
"rationale_refs": [
"scene:5",
"scene:27"
]
}
],
"doorways": [
{
"from_unit": "entry_alcove",
"to_unit": "bathroom",
"edge_hint": "east"
},
{
"from_unit": "living_dining",
"to_unit": "private_bedroom_a",
"edge_hint": "east"
},
{
"from_unit": "living_dining",
"to_unit": "private_bedroom_b",
"edge_hint": "east"
}
],
"windows": [
{
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"edge_hint": "west",
"marker_number": 11
},
{
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"edge_hint": "east",
"marker_number": 12
}
],
"fixtures": [
{
"number": 1,
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"cell": [
3,
5
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 2,
"unit_id": "kitchen_nook",
"cell": [
2,
1
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 3,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
8,
7
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 4,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_b",
"cell": [
8,
2
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 5,
"unit_id": "bathroom",
"cell": [
4,
9
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 6,
"unit_id": "entry_alcove",
"cell": [
1,
9
],
"render_mode": "area_marker"
},
{
"number": 7,
"unit_id": "entry_alcove",
"cell": [
1,
10
],
"anchor_edge": "south",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 8,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
6,
6
],
"anchor_edge": "west",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 9,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_b",
"cell": [
6,
3
],
"anchor_edge": "west",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 10,
"unit_id": "bathroom",
"cell": [
3,
9
],
"anchor_edge": "west",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 11,
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"cell": [
0,
5
],
"anchor_edge": "west",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 12,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
10,
7
],
"anchor_edge": "east",
"render_mode": "opening_marker"
},
{
"number": 13,
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"cell": [
3,
5
],
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 14,
"unit_id": "kitchen_nook",
"cell": [
2,
0
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 15,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
8,
5
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 16,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_b",
"cell": [
8,
0
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 17,
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"cell": [
5,
0
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 18,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
9,
7
],
"render_mode": "floor_marker"
},
{
"number": 19,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
7,
6
],
"render_mode": "floor_marker"
},
{
"number": 20,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
8,
5
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "wall_marker"
},
{
"number": 21,
"unit_id": "bathroom",
"cell": [
4,
8
],
"anchor_edge": "north",
"render_mode": "wall_marker"
},
{
"number": 22,
"unit_id": "living_dining",
"cell": [
2,
5
],
"render_mode": "furniture_symbol"
},
{
"number": 23,
"unit_id": "private_bedroom_a",
"cell": [
7,
5
],
"render_mode": "floor_marker"
}
],
"adjacency_notes": [
"The living dining area operates as the central hub, openly connected to the entry alcove to the southwest and the kitchen nook to the northwest.",
"The entry alcove serves as an interior threshold providing immediate access to a compact bathroom to the southeast.",
"Two fully enclosed private bedrooms sit along the eastern edge of the layout, cleanly separated from each other but accessible via individual doors from the main living zone."
],
"layout_rationale": "The layout structures the apartment with a clear separation between the communal day-use areas on the west side and the completely segregated, enclosed night-use rooms on the east. The open-plan combination of the entry alcove, living zone, and kitchen nook allows for spatial flow and cross-ventilation, terminating at sliding windows on opposing east/west walls. The primary bedroom and secondary bedroom are distinct spatial units occupying the southeast and northeast corners, satisfying the requirement for standalone enclosures while maximizing privacy from the main living spaces."
}
}
}